Advertisement 1

Liberals leave a shocking mess

Article content

It won’t be long before the Ontario Liberals start blaming the Progressive Conservatives for the financial mess they’ve left us in after 15 years in power.

You can already see it happening in some smug media commentary, gleefully predicting Premier-designate Doug Ford and the PCs are going to be a disaster.

In reality, outgoing premier Kathleen Wynne and the Liberals are the disaster — and they have created massive fiscal problems that will take decades, if ever, to correct.

Today, let’s examine the biggest financial train wreck the Liberals have left us to address — the skyrocketing cost of electricity due to the idiotic way they blundered into green energy.

According to a report by Ontario’s Financial Accountability Office, the per-unit cost of solar power to Ontario ratepayers as the Liberals leave office is a staggering $480 per megawatt hour (MWh), wind $173/MWh, biofuels $131/MWh.

That compares to $69/MWh for nuclear power and $58/MWh for hydro.

(Hat tip to Jeffrey Simpson for referencing these numbers in a recent Globe and Mail column.)

The Liberals saddled us with these outrageous costs for green energy despite repeated warnings from two auditors general, starting just two years after they passed the Green Energy Act in 2009.

From 2011 on, the Liberals were repeatedly told that by ignoring the advice of their own energy experts, they were forcing hydro residential and business ratepayers into paying billions of dollars more for renewable energy than was needed to reach the Liberals’ green energy targets.

In 2015, Auditor General Bonnie Lysyk pegged this added cost at $9.2 billion over 20 years, with Ontario hydro consumers paying 3.5 times the U.S. average for solar power, twice the average for wind power.

To be clear, Lysyk didn’t say the Liberals were wasting $9.2 billion by buying green energy over cheaper forms of power.

She said they overpaid $9.2 billion for green energy because they ignored expert advice that the contracts they were handing out to green energy developers were extravagant and unnecessary to meet the government’s goal of eliminating coal-fired electricity, to reduce pollution and greenhouse gases.

Combined with other Liberal electricity blunders documented by Lysyk (such as the gas plants scandal, doubling smart meter costs, turning Hydro One into one of Canada’s least reliable large electricity distributors) the impact on hydro prices was devastating.

They soared to the highest in Canada.

Between 2008 and 2016, average residential electricity costs increased by 71% in Ontario, compared to 34% across Canada, according to Lakehead University economics professor Livio Di Matteo in a recent report for the Fraser Institute.

In 2016, Toronto residents were paying $720 annually more for electricity than the average Canadian.

Between 2010 and 2016, electricity costs for large industrial users in Toronto increased 53% and in Ottawa 43%, compared to a Canadian average of 14%.

That led to the loss of 75,000 manufacturing jobs between 2008 and 2015 alone.

Ford and the PCs can be faulted for not explaining during the election how bad things are.

Alarmingly, Ford promised to continue Wynne’s Fair Hydro Plan, using unconscionable levels of new hydro debt to temporarily lower electricity prices by 25% before sending them into the stratosphere, as well as promising a further 12% cut.

But it was the Liberals who created this mess, for which we’ll be paying for decades to come.

 

Article content
Advertisement 2
Advertisement
Article content
Article content
Latest National Stories
    News Near North Bay
      This Week in Flyers